In 2017, journalists unearthed a remarkable film. Made in 1991 by Shell, one of the world's biggest oil companies, it warned that climate change caused by burning fossil fuels could bring extreme weather, floods, famine and people forced from their homes. The film had been intended for schools and universities, then largely forgotten. Its rediscovery became part of a wider debate about what oil companies knew about climate change, and when.

"Climate of Concern"
The 28-minute film, called Climate of Concern, was made for public viewing, particularly in schools and universities. It explained the greenhouse effect and warned that a warming world could see more extreme weather, rising seas, floods, famines and climate refugees. It was obtained by the Dutch journalism platform De Correspondent and shared with The Guardian, which reported on it in 2017. Climate scientist Tom Wigley, who advised on the film, later called it "one of the best little films that I have seen on climate change ever".
What did Shell know about climate change?
The film was not Shell's first look at the problem. De Correspondent also uncovered a confidential Shell report from 1988, titled The Greenhouse Effect. Written by the company's own experts, it estimated that Shell's products accounted for about 4 per cent of global carbon emissions in 1984, and warned that the potential effects were so large that action might need to be considered well before the end of the century.
When the film resurfaced, a Shell spokesperson said the company's position on climate change was well known. Critics argue that the company kept investing heavily in oil and gas for decades despite what its own experts were saying, and research has found it took years before Shell warned its shareholders about climate risks.
Shell in court
The documents became part of a growing wave of climate litigation. In the Netherlands, the environmental group Milieudefensie took Shell to court, and on 26 May 2021, a district court in The Hague ordered the company to cut its global carbon emissions sharply by 2030. It was the first time a court had ordered a company to reduce its emissions in this way.
Shell appealed, and in November 2024 the Hague Court of Appeal overturned the order. However, it agreed that Shell has a duty of care, under unwritten law and human rights, to reduce its emissions. It simply rejected the specific cut that Milieudefensie had asked for. The campaigners have taken the case to the Supreme Court of the Netherlands, which heard it in 2026, and a final ruling is awaited.

Thirty-five years on
Many of the warnings in Shell's 1991 film have since come true: global temperatures, extreme heat, wildfires and flooding have all increased, just as climate scientists predicted. The film is now often cited as evidence that the oil industry understood the risks of its products decades ago. Whether that knowledge brings legal consequences is a question the courts are still deciding.
Sources
- The Guardian via inkl: Shell's 1991 warning (February 2017)
- Grist: Shell's 1991 climate change film shows just how much it knew (2017)
- DeSmog: Shell took 16 years to warn shareholders of climate risks (2018)
- The Hague Court of Appeal: Court denies claim for reduction in Shell's CO2 emissions (November 2024)
- DutchNews: Campaigners take Shell CO2 case to the Supreme Court (February 2025)
- E&E News: Dutch Supreme Court to decide Shell's duty to slash emissions (2026)














Leave a reply