Forgot to take the steak out of the freezer? According to one well-known test, that may be no bad thing. The claim that steak cooked from frozen beats steak that has been thawed first went viral several years ago, and it comes from a genuine experiment by the cooks at America's Test Kitchen. Here is what they did, what they found, and the caveats.

The test
The Test Kitchen cut a strip loin into eight steaks, then cut each steak in half. Every half was vacuum-sealed and frozen. One half of each steak was then thawed overnight in the fridge, while its twin stayed frozen. Both were cooked the same way: seared in a hot pan, then finished in a low oven until the centre reached medium-rare.
What they found
- Less grey meat. The frozen steaks had a thinner band of overcooked grey meat under the crust. Because the centre starts so cold, the outside can brown hard without the heat creeping too far inside.
- Juicier. On average, the frozen steaks lost 9 per cent less moisture during cooking than the thawed ones.
- Slower. The trade-off is time in the oven: around 18 to 22 minutes for the frozen steaks, against 10 to 15 for the thawed ones.
It is worth keeping this in proportion. It was a kitchen test, not a peer-reviewed study, and the Test Kitchen still says a fresh, never-frozen steak is best. The finding is that, if your steak is frozen anyway, thawing it does not help.

How to do it
- Freeze it flat. Wrap each steak tightly and freeze it on a tray so it stays flat and makes full contact with the pan, then bag it to protect against freezer burn.
- Choose a thick cut. Rib-eye and strip steaks work well. Thin cuts such as flank and skirt overcooked too fast.
- Sear hard. Heat a thin layer of oil, about 3mm deep, in a large frying pan until it shimmers, then sear the frozen steaks for about 90 seconds a side. Take care: frozen meat can make hot oil spit.
- Finish low and slow. Move them to an oven at 135°C (275°F) until the centre reaches your preferred doneness, checking with a meat thermometer, then rest for 10 minutes.
The same idea works on a barbecue: sear over the hottest part of the grill, then move the steaks to the cooler side to finish.
Is it safe?
Yes. The US Department of Agriculture says meat can safely be cooked from frozen, as long as you allow roughly 50 per cent more cooking time. A thermometer is the best way to be sure it is done. In fact, cooking from frozen avoids one common mistake: leaving meat to thaw on the kitchen worktop, which food safety agencies advise against.













Leave a reply