Dads are jerks or dummies; moms are weak or mean.
Fred and Wilma. Peter and Lois. Homer and Marge. Study each couple and you’ll find a troubling trend: The dads fall neatly into two (equally unattractive) categories — inept buffoon or emotionally detached grump — and the moms are either overbearing shrews or feckless nags.

Some researchers believe that this formula isn’t the benign comedy it appears — that it could, in fact, be harming the real-life nuclear family by representing a one- or two-note model of how things should be.
Why dads get a bad rap
An Atlantic article about TV dads quotes author Hanna Rosin:
If there is a dad in the home [on TV], he is an idiot. It must have reflected our own discomfort with dads being competent. Until very recently, a guy who wanted to stay at home or be earnest about fatherhood could not see his image reflected on TV, which essentially meant he did not exist.
The Atlantic isn’t the only outlet concerned with how TV talks about the old man. The Washington Times covered the issue recently, and a UMass Amherst researcher wrote about it back in 2001. The two share a theory: A TV father’s competence is a function of both time and class. Meaning that the farther back we go in time, the more likely we are to have a brainy (if not emotionally involved) dad. Similarly, the higher up the financial ladder a family is, the less likely that Dad is the butt of its jokes.
As women entered the workforce starting in the 1950s and 60s, men spent more time with their children. By the turn of the century, the father-as-breadwinner thing was no longer the sacred reality of earlier decades. To reflect that new truth, shows began to take the newspaper-reading strongman and turn him into Homer Simpson or Hal Wilkerson or Phil Dunphy. Let’s call this shift the “Post-Breadwinner era.”
The real-life development of a family’s financial composition translated to an evolution of Family Sitcom dads. And with the evolution of dads came, inevitably, the evolution of moms.
TV moms suffer from real-life boon
You’d think that as more women pursued professional careers and shed the restrictive social doctrines of the 1940s and 50s, TV would shift to reflect that new empowerment. But just as it mistook the father’s new increase in family responsibility for weakness and stupidity, so did it take the feminist boom as an opportunity to paint moms in an unflattering light.
New school

Witness mothers like Lois Wilkerson of “Malcolm In The Middle” or Claire Dunphy from “Modern Family.” On paper, both satisfy the mother-kn0ws-best trope. Claire and Lois are, after all, empirically smarter than their husbands. But because those shows were both made in and take place in the Post-Breadwinner era, the fathers are bumbling dopes. (For whatever reason — residual misogyny? bad writing? — Phil and Hal are, paradoxically, more professionally successful than their wives.)
This imbalance of smarts results in Lois and Claire becoming the “Bad Guys.” Phil and Hal are kind, loving fathers, but not especially talented ones. From that gentle incompetence comes the don’t-tell-your-mother phenomenon, in which father and child ally themselves against the shrewish mom who is, in most cases, simply trying to keep some semblance of order.















Leave a reply