Friday 20 November 2026 TRENDING
Making a Murderer: What Happened After the Judge Ordered New Evidence TestsThe Grand Tour's 'Gypsies' Joke: The Row That Greeted Clarkson's Amazon Debut, and How the Show EndedThe Films of 2016, Ten Years On: The Year We Were Thankful For, and What It BecameJosh Duggar: From 2016 Comeback Talk to a Federal Prison SentencePelosi vs Tim Ryan, Ten Years On: The 2016 Leadership Fight and the Long Goodbye That FollowedRemembering Alison Parker and Adam Ward, the Journalists Killed on Live TelevisionGilmore Girls: A Year in the Life, Ten Years On: The Cliffhanger That Never Got an AnswerWhat Children in Japan Learn at School That Most of Us Never DidStanding Rock, Ten Years On: From the Eviction Notice to the Pipeline's Final ApprovalFidel Castro Died Ten Years Ago. Here Is the Cuba He Left BehindMaking a Murderer: What Happened After the Judge Ordered New Evidence TestsThe Grand Tour's 'Gypsies' Joke: The Row That Greeted Clarkson's Amazon Debut, and How the Show EndedThe Films of 2016, Ten Years On: The Year We Were Thankful For, and What It BecameJosh Duggar: From 2016 Comeback Talk to a Federal Prison SentencePelosi vs Tim Ryan, Ten Years On: The 2016 Leadership Fight and the Long Goodbye That FollowedRemembering Alison Parker and Adam Ward, the Journalists Killed on Live TelevisionGilmore Girls: A Year in the Life, Ten Years On: The Cliffhanger That Never Got an AnswerWhat Children in Japan Learn at School That Most of Us Never DidStanding Rock, Ten Years On: From the Eviction Notice to the Pipeline's Final ApprovalFidel Castro Died Ten Years Ago. Here Is the Cuba He Left Behind
ThisissNews NEWS & ENTERTAINMENT
Home›Blog
Blog

InsideAirbnb's Report Isn’t Worth The Digital Ink It Is Printed On

Photo: Bobulous, CC BY-SA 4.0 · Representative image

This week, the anti-home sharing website InsideAirbnb released an outrageous—and outrageously shoddy—new report that made a series of sweeping conclusions about the nature of the Airbnb host community in historically Black neighborhoods in New York City, asserting that Airbnb is promoting “racial gentrification.”

Unfortunately, the report isn’t worth the digital ink it is printed on. Rather, it uses a long-discredited methodology akin to racial profiling. Furthermore, this so-called study lacks the control group necessary in any legitimate study, relies on the false assumption that the racial demographics of a particular community’s resident population match the racial demographics of that community’s homeowner population, and fails to address wide disparities between neighborhoods analyzed.

Each of these flaws is examined further, below.

Airbnb does not ask hosts or guests for information related to their racial identity. As a result, the authors of this report attempted to determine the race of individual hosts by using suspect technology to rifle through Airbnb users’ profile photos. This is not only an offensive way to classify individuals, it’s also replete with flaws. 

Race is a continuum, not a dichotomy. And yet, this report only compares two races: Black and White, ignoring the diverse people who call New York City home, including the nearly 285,000 New Yorkers who identify as more than one race. Indeed, since 1970, the Census Bureau has asked Americans to “self-identify” on the federal census, acknowledging that race is not as simple as a photograph.

The methodology does not address Latinos who identify as Black, Whites who identify as Latino, or any other combination, let alone how to categorize a host that is a member of a multiracial couple whose spouse/partner is not pictured on Airbnb.

The bottom line is that the only way to effectively determine race is to have self-identification data from the hosts—and InsideAirbnb doesn’t have it.

Furthermore, while the author uses self-identification data from the Census to identify the race of residents, racial information for Airbnb hosts is not derived from self-identification. As a result, the comparisons between residents and hosts are fundamentally flawed.

One of the first lessons of Research 101 is that any legitimate study has to have an experimental group and a control group to measure against. However, this study has no control group. Instead, even setting aside the concerns raised in #1 above, the author only analyzes disparities between residents and Airbnb hosts in Black neighborhoods. Without performing a similar analysis in White neighborhoods, they cannot rule out alternative explanations for the disparity. 

It is possible, for instance, that a disproportionate share of Airbnb hosts are White because White New Yorkers are significantly more likely than Black or Hispanic New Yorkers to own their homes (42 percent of Non-Hispanic White New Yorkers own their homes, only 27 percent of Black New Yorkers and 15 percent of Hispanic households own theirs).

This leads us to another fundamental flaw in this report: the reliance on the demographic profile of residents, but not the demographic profile of homeowners. In many situations, renters are forbidden― either by the Multiple Dwelling Law or by the terms of their lease― to rent out their homes on a short-term basis. This includes all rent-stabilized tenants, as well as tenants in public housing or who use federal or local vouchers to pay rent. These latter groups are disproportionately people of color. In fact, as of January 1, 2015, over 90 percent of NYCHA’s population identified as Black or Hispanic.

Filed underBlog

More From: Blog

View all →

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Thanks for joining in! Comments are being switched back on after our relaunch, so yours couldn't be posted just yet.

You may also like

Celebrities

Tosca Reno, Author of the Eat-Clean Diet, Interview with E! News

Tosca Reno, author of the Eat-Clean Diet and her newest book, “Just the Rules” speaks with E! News. Air Date: January 23, 2012

13 February 20171 min read
Fashion

Crocodile Pendants Chunky Statement Necklace

Crocodile Pendants Chunky Statement Necklace Fashion Crocodile Pendants Chunky Statement Necklace Free 1. Material: Metal Chunky chain with alloy Crocodile Animal pendants, inlay w

31 October 20161 min read
Funny

Last Words Of Boy Who Was Decapitated On Water Slide Are Revealed By His Parents

For most families, a day out at a waterpark results in nothing more than racing hearts and a bit of accidentally swallowed chlorine. However, for one Kansas family, a day out at th

15 February 20171 min read
Basketball

Tristan Thompson out tonight against Celtics, games-played streak ends at 447

Cleveland Cavaliers vs Orlando Magic, April 4, 2017 Orlando Magic guard Evan Fournier has to pass the ball in the midst of the Cleveland Cavaliers defense of center Tristan Thompso

5 April 20171 min read
Funny

Here Are 6 Tricks To Making A Better Cup Of Coffee According To Coffee Experts

I love a good cup of coffee. Now more than ever, a quality cup of Joe is easier to find. There are plenty of independent cafes and coffee shops serving the best brewed beans around

5 April 20171 min read
Entertainment

Dad buys a cat. When he tells his dog, he responds in hysterical fashion

We’ve all wondered what would happen if our pets could talk. Instead of staying curious, one man decided to create a conversation with his dog. The man behind this chat is Andrew G

29 July 20172 min read

Don't Miss

View all →

Disclaimer

Thisissnews aims to update, educate, uplift and entertain you. Rather than have stories lower our faith in humanity, Thisissnews aims to inspire and uplift. We carry a belief that media companies should not focus on what will generate page views, but rather a media company should be dedicated to enriching and impacting the lives of its readers.

Follow us

Get the best viral stories straight into your inbox!

Don't worry, we don't spam
Thanks! Our newsletter is being relaunched; sign-ups open very soon.

Recent comments